P0420 Code: Catalyst Efficiency Below Threshold - Causes & Fix Cost

Your OBD2 scanner shows P0420 and your first thought is "there goes two grand on a catalytic converter." But here's the thing: in many cases, P0420 is triggered by a failing O2 sensor, an exhaust leak, or an underlying engine problem rather than the converter itself. Before you panic, let's figure out what's actually going on.

What P0420 Means (The Short Version)

Your catalytic converter's job is chemistry: it takes carbon monoxide (CO), hydrocarbons (HC), and nitrogen oxides (NOx) from the exhaust and converts them into water vapour, nitrogen, and carbon dioxide. When it's working properly, it effectively "consumes" oxygen during this chemical reaction.

Your car monitors this with two oxygen sensors: one upstream (before the converter) and one downstream (after it). The upstream sensor fluctuates rapidly as the engine constantly adjusts the fuel mixture. The downstream sensor, if the converter is doing its job, should show a much smoother, more stable signal.

When the downstream sensor starts mimicking the rapid fluctuations of the upstream sensor, the engine computer knows the converter isn't storing and releasing oxygen properly. That's when it sets P0420.

P0430 is the same code for Bank 2, relevant if you have a V6 or V8 with catalytic converters on both sides.

A note on sensor types: The voltage-based diagnostics described in this guide apply to conventional narrowband O2 sensors, which switch between approximately 0.1 V and 0.9 V. Many modern European vehicles (particularly VW, Audi, BMW, and Mercedes from roughly 2005 onward) use wideband (lambda) sensors instead. Wideband sensors display a lambda value rather than a switching voltage. On a wideband sensor, look for a stable reading near lambda 1.0 (approximately 14.7:1 AFR) on the upstream, and a steady downstream reading that differs from the upstream pattern. The diagnostic logic is the same: if the downstream sensor closely mirrors the upstream, the converter isn't doing its job.

Symptoms

P0420 itself doesn't always produce obvious symptoms beyond the check engine light. But depending on how far gone the converter is, you might notice:

• Slightly reduced fuel economy, typically 2-5%. A larger drop (5-10%) usually points to an underlying engine problem such as misfires or rich running that's both damaging the converter and hurting efficiency.
• A sulphur or "rotten egg" smell from the exhaust
• Failed emissions test or vehicle inspection (MOT, TUV/HU, ITV, etc.)
• Reduced engine performance (in severe cases where the converter is physically blocked)
• A rattling noise from underneath the car (if the converter's internal honeycomb structure is breaking apart)

If the converter is so far gone that it's physically blocking exhaust flow, you'll feel a noticeable loss of power, especially under acceleration. That's uncommon but worth knowing about.

Common Causes (In Order of Likelihood)

Aging Converter (Most Common)

After 150,000+ km, the converter's internal honeycomb structure degrades. The precious metals (platinum, palladium, rhodium) that catalyse the chemical reactions get contaminated, the ceramic substrate breaks down, and efficiency drops below the threshold. This is natural wear: converters don't last forever.

If the code appeared gradually on a high-mileage car with no other issues, this is the most likely cause. Cost: €500 to €2,500 for parts and labour. European vehicles with integrated manifold catalytic converters (common on many VW, BMW, and Mercedes models) can exceed €3,000.

Failing Downstream O2 Sensor (Common, ~25-35% of Cases)

Here's why you should never skip diagnostics and jump straight to converter replacement. The downstream oxygen sensor is the component that monitors converter efficiency. If that sensor is sluggish, reading incorrectly, or giving erratic voltage, it will trigger P0420 even with a perfectly healthy converter.

A healthy narrowband downstream sensor should show relatively stable readings averaging around 0.4-0.6 V. If it's erratic, stuck at a fixed voltage, or mirroring the upstream sensor's rapid switching, the sensor is the problem. Cost: €150 to €300 with labour, €50 to €150 for the part. OEM wideband lambda sensors on European vehicles can run €150 to €300+ for the part alone.

Exhaust Leak Before the Converter (Less Common)

A leak in the exhaust before the converter lets fresh outside air mix into the exhaust stream, confusing the oxygen sensors. This is especially common after recent exhaust work, or on older vehicles with rusty exhaust manifold gaskets.

Signs: a louder-than-normal exhaust, visible soot marks around joints, or a hissing/ticking sound that increases with RPM (especially when the engine is cold, before thermal expansion seals the gaps). Cost: €80 to €300.

Underlying Engine Problem (Less Common)

Persistent misfires dump unburned fuel into the converter. A rich-running engine coats the catalyst material. Oil burning contaminates the precious metals. In all these cases, the converter is a victim, not the root cause. If you see P0420 alongside misfire codes (P0300 series), lean/rich codes (P0171/P0172), or you're burning oil, fix the engine problem first. The converter may recover once it's no longer being abused.

A lean-running engine can also damage the converter over time by causing it to overheat. If you're seeing P0171 (system too lean) alongside P0420, the lean condition is likely the underlying cause.

Fuel or Fluid Contamination (Uncommon)

Bad fuel, oil in the exhaust from worn valve seals, or coolant leaking into combustion chambers (head gasket issue) can all contaminate the converter. If P0420 appeared after filling up at an unfamiliar station, or you're seeing white or blue smoke from the exhaust, contamination is worth investigating.

Diagnosis: How to Figure Out the Actual Cause

Step 1: Read All Codes

P0420 alone is one thing. P0420 plus misfire codes, lean codes, or O2 sensor codes tells a completely different story. Read everything first.

• P0300 series (misfires) = urgent, stop driving: misfires destroy converters
• P0171/P0172 (lean/rich) = may have caused converter damage over time
• P0135-P0161 (O2 sensor codes) = sensor issue, probably not the converter

Step 2: Check O2 Sensor Readings

Using live data from Skanyx or another scanner that shows O2 sensor voltage, compare the upstream and downstream sensor patterns:

• Upstream sensor (narrowband): Should switch rapidly between ~0.1 V and ~0.9 V
• Downstream sensor (narrowband): Should be relatively stable, averaging 0.4-0.6 V

If downstream readings mirror upstream readings closely, the converter genuinely isn't working. If downstream readings are stuck or erratic in a way that doesn't match the upstream pattern, suspect the sensor itself.

Skanyx's AI analysis can flag abnormal O2 sensor behaviour and help determine whether the sensor or the converter is the more likely culprit. Try it free at skanyx.com/download

Step 3: Visual Inspection

Look for exhaust leaks: soot marks, rust holes, loose connections. Listen for hissing or ticking. Check for physical damage to the converter (dents, rust-through). Shake the converter (carefully, when cold) and listen for rattling, which indicates the internal substrate has broken apart.

Step 4: The Temperature Test

If you have an infrared thermometer (available for €15 to €25), this is a genuinely useful diagnostic. Measure the temperature at the converter inlet and outlet. The outlet should be 10-20% hotter than the inlet because the chemical reaction generates heat. On older vehicles or engines not running cleanly, the difference can be 30 to 55 degrees C or more. Modern fuel-efficient engines running cleanly may show a smaller temperature rise, so a modest difference doesn't necessarily mean the converter has failed.

If the outlet is the same temperature or cooler than the inlet, the converter isn't catalysing properly.

Step 5: Oxygen Storage Capacity Test

A professional can perform an oxygen storage capacity test, which is the most conclusive diagnostic for converter health. This involves commanding the engine rich, then lean, and measuring how long the downstream sensor takes to respond. A healthy converter delays the response because it stores and releases oxygen. A failing converter passes the change through quickly, and the downstream sensor reacts almost immediately.

Step 6: Check for Software Updates (TSBs)

On some vehicles, a PCM/ECU software update resolves P0420 without any hardware replacement. Manufacturers issue Technical Service Bulletins (TSBs) when they discover the original calibration triggers false P0420 codes. This is particularly common on certain Honda, Subaru, and Toyota models. Check for TSBs specific to your make, model, and year before committing to hardware replacement.

Step 7: Check Vehicle History

Mileage over 150,000 km? Natural aging. Recent engine problems that went unfixed? Probably damaged the converter secondarily. Oil consumption issues? Contamination over time.

Repair Cost Breakdown

These percentages are estimates based on repair data and vary by vehicle age, make, and driving conditions. EU emission compliance: In the EU, replacement catalytic converters must meet the applicable Euro emission standard for your vehicle. Using a non-compliant converter can cause your vehicle to fail the periodic inspection (TUV/HU, MOT, ITV, etc.) and may be illegal. OEM or EU-type-approved converters are recommended. CARB compliance (US only): If you're in California, New York, or other CARB-compliant states, you can't use universal aftermarket converters. You need CARB-certified units, which often cost 2-3x more than standard aftermarket converters. Converter theft note: Catalytic converter theft has increased significantly in recent years due to the value of the precious metals inside (platinum, palladium, rhodium). If you're buying a used car, check that the converter is original and not a cheap aftermarket replacement or missing entirely. This is exactly the kind of thing a pre-purchase inspection catches. Critical rule: Always diagnose the root cause before replacing the converter. If an engine problem caused the failure, a new converter will fail the same way.

Can You Keep Driving?

With only P0420 and no other codes, no rough running, no strange smells: yes, short-term driving is fine. The converter is still working, just at reduced efficiency. The main consequences are failing an emissions test and a small hit to fuel economy.

Stop driving immediately if you have P0420 plus misfire codes (P0300 series), a flashing check engine light, or noticeable power loss (which could indicate the converter is physically blocking exhaust flow: rare but serious, and a potential fire hazard from extreme heat).

Prevention

Converters fail for two reasons: age and abuse. You can't prevent aging, but you can prevent abuse:

• Fix misfires immediately. Every misfired combustion cycle dumps raw fuel into the converter.
• Don't ignore oil burning. Oil coats the precious metals inside the converter and reduces their effectiveness over time.
• Keep up with oil changes. Good oil condition means less blow-by and less contamination reaching the converter.
• Use quality fuel. Consistent fuel quality reduces contamination risk.
• Address exhaust leaks promptly. They confuse O2 sensors and can lead to incorrect fuelling that stresses the converter.

A monthly OBD2 scan catches developing problems before they cascade. A €50 O2 sensor fix now prevents a €2,000 converter replacement later.

A monthly scan with Skanyx tracks your vehicle's health over time. If fuel trim values start creeping upward or O2 sensor response times slow down, you'll catch the trend before it turns into a P0420 code and a potential converter replacement. Download Skanyx free at skanyx.com/download

---

Related: What is OBD2? | P0171: System Too Lean | OBD2 Live Data Explained | Common Car Problems